West of the Moon

A Tolkien Fanfiction Archive


Reviews for Rain:

Back to Story Listing

Name: Frodosweetstuff Date: 2008-02-18 04:11
Oh, this is one of the first F/S fics that I read and it always had a special place in my heart. Love what Sam says to Frodo when he comes to bring him back to Hobbiton, that is so very moving. Thank you! Excellent story!

Name: Shannon Date: 2006-03-05 13:12
Email: shannsey@yahoo.com
This is honestly one of the best F/S stories I have ever read. The characterization is remarkably accurate; I could hear Frodo and Sam saying every line of dialogue in my head. And the language is so lyrical and engaging. Wonderful!

Name: jennie Date: 2004-04-09 09:03
Please write more of this! I loved it! They are all so very cute!

Name: Drew Date: 2004-02-03 20:41
Email: dwildstar30@yahoo.com
A nice twist on the old (but always loveable) story of Frodo and Sam. True to say it's a heart breaker in a few places but very moving.

Name: SeaLoam Date: 2003-08-01 13:24
Email: myrtalea@aol.com
One of the best I've read. Wonderfully exquisite charactorizations. Frodo is devastating. Very convincingly a one-of-a-kind hobbit. (no wonder he was chosen to save middle-earth!)I love the combination of him being edgy and strong and yet shows a sensitivity and vulnerability--fragility. And the others are also very very captivating. Really beautiful and riviting. Dialog is dead on in tone and language. Quite interesting...