West of the Moon

A Tolkien Fanfiction Archive


Reviews for Bearer of the Ring (with audio):

Back to Story Listing

Name: Aratlithiel Date: 2003-08-31 22:39
Email: AratlithielTinuviel@hotmail.com
Ahhh - absolutely lovely. Everything I expected; touching, poignant, sad, angsty. Such a depth of feeling here. 'Death you meant to welcome Sweet surrender, end of strife. But pain was not to end for you, For you were granted life.' I've always wondered how much of Frodo being 'granted' life was a blessing and how much was a curse...? You've managed to capture the irony here and give it a heart-wrenching twist. Beautiful as I knew it would be and I'll tell you again what a lovely voice you have. Fabulous.