West of the Moon
A Tolkien Fanfiction Archive
Reviews for Earth:
| Name: Budgielover | Date: 2004-10-19 01:53 |
| Email: budgielover_1@netzero.com | |
| I am so glad to see this story added to your others here. I spent part of my evening tonight downloading the three other parts of this series onto my hard drive, so I could read them later. After throughly enjoying this story, I looked for your others on FF.Net and SOA, only to email our beloved Marigold to ask if she knew where I could find your others when I couldn't find them on those sites. I look forward to reading them. But let me tell you how much I enjoyed this story. The plot twists and turns, the characterizations of our beloved hobbits, the description of the fair - all perfect. Frodo being a judge of the wine table had me in stitches, and I loved scrappy!Pippin and how the others tried to protect him from the larger lads. Sam was beautifully portrayed, honest and upright as the Shire itself. All of the hobbits were wonderful. This story left me feeling warm and fuzzy and laughing and amazed at your talent. | |